Book Review: Maybe in Another Life by Taylor Jenkins Reid
So, I’ve read a few of Taylor Jenkins Reid’s books in the past, and each time I’m left thinking, “Well, that was entertaining and thought-provoking.” But more than that, her books dive into the complexities of human nature, exploring the deep search for meaning in life—whether it’s about love, fame, identity, or those moments when we try to figure out who we really are. Maybe in Another Life is no exception. It’s a compelling mix of soul-searching, decisions, and wondering, “What the heck am I doing with my life?” if you’ve ever found yourself in that deep spiral of thoughts.
Meet Hannah Martin—Your New Relatable Book Bestie
Let’s talk about the star of this story: Hannah Martin, a twenty-nine-year-old who might just be the most relatable character I’ve encountered in a long time. Hannah is, like many of us at some point, really trying to figure her life out. She’s been to multiple cities, had jobs that are as forgettable as her romantic life, and—spoiler alert—not everything is together. But who really has it all figured out?
One Decision, Two Realities
After a particularly disastrous breakup, Hannah returns to her hometown in LA. When her best friend Gabby invites her out for a night on the town, Hannah unexpectedly runs into her high school boyfriend. Then comes the twist: the story splits in two. Maybe in Another Life explores both realities—what happens if she leaves with him and what happens if she doesn’t. Two timelines. Two possible futures. One big “what if?”
It might feel a little confusing at first, but stick with it. It all weaves together in a really satisfying way.
The Real Takeaway: Our Choices Shape Everything
What struck me most was how this book shows the domino effect of even the smallest choices. Like deciding to stay five extra minutes at a party. Or answering a text. The beauty of Maybe in Another Life is that it doesn’t judge the outcome—it just invites you to think: What if I had chosen differently?
As someone who can barely choose what to eat for lunch, Hannah’s indecision felt so real. If you’re perpetually torn between options and afraid of making the wrong choice, this book will hit home.
Fate or Free Will? A Question We All Face
At its core, Maybe in Another Life is about fate, second chances, and the roads we don’t take. Are our lives shaped by random moments or are we following some bigger plan? Is there one true love, one soulmate, or can love grow in many ways depending on the path we choose?
These questions linger long after the last page. And maybe that’s the point—life isn’t always about getting it “right,” but about embracing the story as it unfolds.
Final Thoughts
In conclusion, Maybe in Another Life is the kind of book that’ll make you laugh, cry, and pause to reflect. You’ll walk away considering your own crossroads—and wondering what small decisions might shape your tomorrow.
If you love emotional stories with a twist of fate, heartfelt characters, and a little bit of existential reflection, this one belongs on your TBR. Because in this life—or maybe in another—this book is worth the read.
Loved this review?
If Maybe in Another Life sounds like your kind of read, check out more of my book reviews, personal reflections, and reader resources over on my blog 💫
